No. 37 Immigration & the border Clearly contradicted

“Millions pouring in from prisons and mental institutions” — no evidence for it at all

“Millions of people pouring into our country from prisons, jails, from mental institutions and insane asylums.”
— Presidential debate — Trump v. Harris (ABC News), 10 September 2024, National Constitution Center, Philadelphia

What it asserts

That foreign governments are systematically emptying their prisons and psychiatric institutions and sending those people to the United States, at million-scale. Trump also said crime in Venezuela and elsewhere is down “because they’ve taken their criminals off the street and they’ve given them to her.”

What the record shows

FactCheck.org: “Immigration experts told us there’s simply no evidence for that. One expert said Trump’s claim appeared to be ‘a total fabrication.’” Trump “hasn’t provided any credible support.” On Venezuela specifically, Roberto Briceño-León of the Venezuelan Observatory of Violence: “We have no evidence that the Venezuelan government is emptying the prisons or mental hospitals to send them out of the country, whether to the USA or any other country.” Experts attribute Venezuela’s crime decline to mass emigration — nearly 8 million people since 2014, mostly to South America — and economic collapse, not prisoner export. PolitiFact separately noted that some migrants do have criminal records, but “no evidence that they add up to millions”.

The claims against the record

Each claim against the recorded evidence
ClaimWhat the record shows
Millions pouring in from prisons, jails, from mental institutions and insane asylumsNo evidence at all, per the immigration experts FactCheck.org consulted; one called it “a total fabrication”. Trump has provided no credible support. PolitiFact: some migrants do have criminal records, but “no evidence that they add up to millions”.
Crime is down in Venezuela because they took their criminals off the street and gave them to the USRoberto Briceño-León, Venezuelan Observatory of Violence: no evidence Venezuela is emptying its prisons or mental hospitals to send people abroad. Experts attribute the crime decline to mass emigration — nearly 8 million people since 2014 — and economic collapse, not prisoner export.

What the evidence actually shows

  • There is no evidence for the systematic claim — immigration experts told FactCheck.org there is simply no evidence that foreign governments are emptying prisons and mental institutions and sending people to the United States, and one expert called the claim “a total fabrication”. Trump has provided no credible support.
  • Venezuela’s crime fall has a different explanation — experts attribute it to mass emigration, nearly 8 million people since 2014, mostly to South America, and to economic collapse. The Venezuelan Observatory of Violence says there is no evidence the government is emptying prisons or mental hospitals to send people out of the country.
  • The grain of truth is small — some migrants do have criminal records, as PolitiFact noted, but there is no evidence they add up to millions. A claim about some individuals is not a claim about a systematic, million-scale policy.
  • So the claim fails on its own terms: it asserts a deliberate, million-scale export of prisoners and psychiatric patients by foreign governments, and no evidence for any part of that mechanism exists.

Fairness note: individual migrants with criminal records do exist, and no dataset tracks “prisoners exported by foreign governments” as a category — so this is not a proven count of zero. What the record does show is that the systematic, million-scale claim has no evidence behind it.

VerdictClearly contradicted: no evidence for the systematic million-scale claim — immigration experts told FactCheck.org there is simply no evidence for it, and one called it “a total fabrication”.

Correction / response

None reported; the claim was repeated in the same debate and throughout 2024.

Checked by: FactCheck.org — FactChecking the Harris-Trump Debate

Related fact-checks