Loading the catalogue…
Could disinfectant and powerful light used inside the body work against Covid — and can anyone have “kept far more promises than I made”? Those are Nos. 28 and 29 in this catalogue of 100 speech and debate claims, each quoted verbatim and checked against primary records and non-partisan fact-checkers.
A checkable number, date, authorship, legal power or event is directly contradicted by the primary record — a law signed in 2014, a vote count of zero, a 63% share claimed as 100%.
The narrow fact underneath is real, but the speech drops the qualifier that changes its meaning — “zero releases” presented as “zero crossings”, or a one-year crime uptick framed as national collapse.
Reputable sources disagree on definitions or the evidence is genuinely ambiguous — what counts as a “war ended”, for instance. These are not labelled simply false.
A statement that floated an idea or proposal rather than asserted a past fact — “is there a way we can do something like that…? It would be interesting to check that.” It is not graded simply as a false past-tense claim. Instead the catalogue checks the idea itself: could it work? For disinfectant and powerful light inside the body, the answer is no as a medical solution — see No. 28. For saving $300 billion a year by negotiating drug prices, the arithmetic fails against total programme spending — see No. 46.
Loading the catalogue…
Not every famous remark is a factual assertion, and forcing it into “true / false” distorts it. The rule now used here is: if the wording floated an idea or asked a question, catalogue it as a suggestion and check whether that suggestion is viable; if the wording is opinion or a sourced position overstated in framing, explain it here rather than counting it as a false claim. Items that are catalogued as full entries in the main catalogue are not repeated here — that includes the former borderline case “greatest economy in history”, now catalogued in full as No. 47. One case is explained below.
Trump’s debate claim that Harris “wants to do transgender operations on illegal aliens that are in prison” was rated Mostly True by PolitiFact, because Harris had answered “yes” to a 2019 ACLU questionnaire supporting medically necessary gender-transition care, including surgical care, for federal prisoners and detainees. Its present-tense framing overstated her 2024 platform — her campaign said that questionnaire “is not what she is proposing or running on” — but it is not included in the main catalogue as a false claim, to avoid labelling a sourced position as false. Source: PolitiFact debate fact-check, 11 September 2024.
Only checkable factual assertions are catalogued as claims. Opinion (“terrible mayor”), promises and future predictions are not counted as false on their own — they appear only where a statement also asserts a present or past fact, such as who pays tariffs now or what revenue has actually been collected. A superlative that asserts a checkable historical ranking is treated the same way: “the greatest economy in history” is catalogued at No. 47 because it can be tested against the broad measures economists use for the whole economy — GDP growth and, separately, the stock market. Scope, widened: speeches, formal addresses, rally speeches and briefings (Nos. 1–29), formal debates (Nos. 30–46) and the converted borderline case at No. 47 (spoken in both a debate and a rally) are now in scope; tweets and interviews alone remain deprioritised. Debate entries Nos. 30–46 were all spoken in a formal debate, not merely repeated at a rally or in an interview. Deduplication: claims Trump repeated in both speeches and debates (e.g. who pays tariffs, Iraq opposition) are included for their debate utterance with debate date and place, cross-referenced to the speech entry rather than treated as a new underlying claim — see Nos. 14 and 35. “No correction reported” means none was found in the sources consulted for that item — for the debate backfill, reported as “none reported in cited sources” — not proof that none exists. Where Trump repeated a claim after a public correction, that is noted, as it is the strongest signal of a contentious, high-profile item. Excluded from the debate backfill: opinions, predictions (“I will end the war in 24 hours”), insults and characterisations of motive, and claims where the evidence was genuinely ambiguous at debate time — including the “transgender operations” claim explained in the borderline section, which PolitiFact rated Mostly True.
Suggestion checks are the one deliberate exception in form. Where a statement did not assert a fact or instruct the public, but floated a course of action — “a statement he made suggesting something” — it is catalogued separately, labelled Suggestion checked, and the check is of the suggestion itself: is it viable, on the medical, scientific, practical or arithmetic evidence? That is the treatment given to the disinfectant and light remarks at No. 28 and to the $300 billion drug-price saving at No. 46. For No. 28 it produces two distinct findings, both kept: (1) the shorthand version (“he told people to inject bleach”) is not accurate; (2) the underlying suggestion is not a viable solution. Neither finding cancels the other.